1st Avenue Wines & Spirits closed recently after, by local accounts, more than 40 years at 383 First Avenue between 22nd & 23rd streets, across from Peter Cooper Village.
There's no "For Lease" sign or message to customers posted on the security gate and the phone rings unanswered, but people we talked to had definite opinions about why the store closed. Most pointed to newly arrived competition, specifically the 3,000-square-foot Morton Williams Wine & Spirits that
opened in April on 23rd Street between First & Second avenues. In competition to come, as we
first reported, Tre Figli got a license in February for a sizable liquor store on First Avenue between 19th & 20th streets in the Stuyvesant Town mall.
 |
| Neighborhood fixture for four decades closed at 383 First Avenue. |
"It seems like the First Avenue wine shop has been across the street forever," said a long-time Peter Cooper Village resident, "but with different owners over the past few years. From the way it looked inside lately, I'm not surprised it closed, but you hate to see anybody go out of business." A local merchant summed up the consensus of other comments, "Why are we losing so many shops and restaurants in our neighborhood? So another bank or pharmacy can open?"
Gone for good or just for now?
We stopped in 1st Avenue Wines & Spirits a few months ago and also picked up a soon-to-be-shuttered vibe, but when we asked, the answer was a resounding "no." Last month, the store looked tidier inside and better stocked, so we wondered if it was under new management, and the answer was "not yet" -- but without elaboration.